Both the Athletic Hall of Fame and the Distinguished Alumni Hall of Fame are sponsored by Carroll's Alumni Association. The Athletic Hall of Fame recognizes individuals who made a “significant athletic contribution” to Archbishop Carroll High School and who have perpetuated the Patriot spirit. Two categories of recognition are Student Athletics and Special Contributors. The first ceremony was held in February of 2003. Selections are made by a volunteer committee chaired by Julie (Staton) Malesko '93 and Chris Youngerman '79 and take into consideration recommendations made from alumni and the Carroll community. For more information, go here.
The Distinguished Alumni Hall of Fame honors post-graduation achievements of alumni, as well as those who have had a lasting and profound effect on Archbishop Carroll High School. The first ceremony was held September 13, 2008, at the Hope Hotel & Conference Center at Wright Patterson Air Force Base. The current selection committee is chaired by Gwyn (Fox) Stump '99. For more information, go here.