Athletic Hall of Fame Guidelines
The next Athletic Hall of Fame Ceremony will be held during Alumni Homecoming Weekend on Saturday, September 26, 2026 at the University of Dayton Daniel J. Curran Place.
Go here to see videos of the most recent Athletic Hall of Fame ceremonies.
The Athletic Hall of Fame Committee was established in 2001 to recognize individuals who have made significant athletic contributions to Archbishop Carroll High School and assist the administration in perpetuating the spirit of pride and loyalty.
There are three categories for consideration; Athletes, Special Contributors, and Teams. Athletes cannot be considered until 10 years after graduation. Athletes must have at least two varsity letters and not have left Carroll due to academic or disciplinary reasons. Their inductions are based on their achievements during high school. Subsequent athletic success may be noted, but is not part of the consideration for induction.
Special Contributors and Teams can be considered at the discretion of the committee.
The volunteer selection committee makes nominations and considers those received from alumni and the community. Members may nominate anyone from any era. Once a candidate is nominated, his/her name cannot be removed from the list unless subsequent research discovers they do not meet the criteria. The committee will have the ultimate authority to make a determination of the nominee's eligibility based on character and fitness of the candidate before or after induction.
You may complete the nomination form here on this website.
Questions? Please contact the chairperson:
Christine Youngerman '79: cyoungerman@carrollhs.org
Athletic Hall of Fame Inductees
.png)
Athletic Inaugural Class of 2003
February 8, 2003
- Front Row, left to right: David Green '78, Frank Klotz, Elita Presutti '91, Teri Hobbs '81, Jeff Popp '83, Mark Frankenberg '86
- Back Row, left to right: Mark Vest '81, Denny Lane '72, Mike Bennett '70, Coach Jim Spoerl, Coach Jim Hemmert, John Neatherton '65, Fred Borgert '67
.png)
Athletic Hall of Fame Class of 2004
February 14, 2004
- Standing, left to right: Pam (Staton) Tipps '91, Steve Hohl '73, John Schneider '71, Don Popp '79, Dave Heider '79, Charlie Beecroft '69, Eugene John Schmitt MD, Jim Kuntz, Howard Burger, Pat West '72
.png)
Athletic Hall of Fame Class of 2005
February 12, 2005
- Standing, left to right: Coach Michael Donohue, Don Fortener '72, Edward Schaeffer '72, Ty Reuber '77, James J. Spoerl '78, Randy Bitsko '86, Matt Leopard '92, Jodi (Bitsko) Dahm '93
.png)
Athletic Hall of Fame Class of 2006
January 28, 2006
- Standing, left to right: Sheryl (Jennings) McGurk '85, Carri (Campbell) Seaman '95, Coach Michael Roberts, Sharon (Beigel) Beck '73, Steve Wolodkiewicz '71, John Agnew '80, not pictured Todd Jones '70
Athletic Hall of Fame Class of 2007
February 17, 2007
- Standing, left to right: Mark Gerhard '72, Dina (Hilgeford) Byrnes '78, Kevin Mosher '74, Pat McDevitt '82, Tim Norbut '82, Tony Ferraro '84, Chris Schmitt '71, Julie (Staton) Malesko '93
.png)
Athletic Hall of Fame Class of 2008
January 19, 2008
- Standing, left to right: Nick Anello '71, Colleen (Edwards) O'Rourke '84, Janet (Emerson) Hollenbeck '83, John Fisher '75, Terry Thill '72, Coach Ron Russo
.JPG)
Athletic Hall of Fame Class of 2009
January 24, 2009
- Standing, left to right: Chris (Barney) Sacksteder '76, John McHale '70, Charlie Middleton '94, Missy Belcher '97, Susan (Blommel) Gates '92, Shawn Blatt '82, not pictured Paul Hilliar III '93
.jpg)
Athletic Hall of Fame Class of 2010
February 13, 2010
- Standing, left to right: Mike Rotterman '66, Pat Kiggins '70, John Kappeler '72, John Schaeffer '76, Christine Youngerman '79, Sarah (Henninger) Dunn '91, Kyle Geswein '98
Athletic Hall of Fame Class of 2011
February 19, 2011
- Standing, left to right: Terry Jones '67, Greg Furderer '81, Aaron Howard '93, Rhonda (Rains) Skare '93, Christin Lacroix '94, Paul Schaeffer '93
.jpg)
Athletic Hall of Fame Class of 2012
February 4, 2012
- Standing, left to right: Coach Scott Molfenter, Jeff Clemens '01, Dan Flaute '95, Nick Germano '90, Phil Long '92, Damian Schmitt '81
Athletic Hall of Fame Class of 2013
September 28, 2013
- Standing, left to right: Glen Manny '72, Matt Rotterman '94, Maria (Sprauer) Bechtold '78, Scott Franz '79, Joey Mauro '98, Coach Steve Bartlett, not pictured Rick Good '69
Athletic Hall of Fame Class of 2015
October 3, 2015
- Standing, left to right: Monica Notestine ’76, Dennis Wahle ’84, Tim Bell ’96, Robyn Swain ’99, Chris Coleman ’02, Nick Terbay ’02, Patrick O’Bryan ‘03
Athletic Hall of Fame Class of 2017
October 21, 2017
- Standing, left to right: Katie (Flaute) Shelton ‘02, Katie (Streck) Clingner ‘04, Terry (Nail) Williams ‘80, Coach Marilyn (Wilson) Hall, Jason Bullens ‘99, Alex VanderSluijs ‘03, Mark DiSalvo ‘00, plus the 1980 State Champion Soccer Team
2017 Athletic Hall of Fame Team Induction
1980 State Champion Soccer Team
Athletic Hall of Fame Class of 2019
October 26, 2019
- Standing, left to right: Lyle Garrison '05, Brittany (Horvath) Stiegemeier '04, Becky (Belcher) Mueller '00, Joe McGarvey '89, Juliet Nail '88, Tom Sableski, Justin Mosher '03, plus the 2008 State Champion Soccer Team
.png)
2019 Athletic Hall of Fame Team Induction
2008 State Champion Soccer Team
Athletic Hall of Fame Class of 2022
October 8, 2022
Standing, left to right: Katie (Ollier) Chu ’11, Stanley Gaither ’76, Shirley Keller (representing deceased husband, Charles Keller, Special Contributor), Brogan (Berry) Magnarelli ’08, Kathy (Pierce) Berry '76 (representing deceased husband, Coach Rob Berry, Special Contributor), Greg Terbay ’98, Jason Riggs ’06; not pictured James Borchers ’02; plus the 1998 State Dual Champion Wrestling Team
.jpg)
Athletic Hall of Fame Class of 2024
October 19, 2024
- Standing, left to right: Jonathon Buschur ’10, Patrick Barrentine ’03, Jeff Popella ’06, Donna Palivec ’70, Jordan Jennewine ’07, Andrew Trick ’09, Kelley Austria ’12; not pictured Jonah Rieman ’13; plus the 2010 State Champion Men’s Soccer Team
Athletic Hall of Fame Class of 2026
September 26, 2026
University of Dayton Daniel J. Curran Place
- Helen (Edgar) Forsythe ‘76: Carroll Volleyball, Basketball, Softball
- Sarah (Rogers) Flach ‘99: Carroll Soccer, Basketball, Softball
- Lauren (Viney) De Coo ‘00: Carroll Volleyball
- Chadd Kiggins ‘11: Carroll Track & Cross Country
- Ryan Dull ‘13: Carroll Tennis, Swimming, Cross Country, Track
- Noah Kummer ‘15: Carroll Basketball & Soccer
- Patrick Hemmert ‘15: Carroll Football, Basketball, Track
2026 Athletic Hall of Fame Team Induction
2011 State Champion Men’s Soccer Team
.jpg)
2012 State Champion Men’s Soccer Team
