Carroll High School is a member of the Ohio High School Athletic Association and new member of the Greater Catholic League for men's teams and the Girls' Greater Cincinnati League for women's teams. Carroll High School's reputation for academic excellence carries over to the athletic programs.

While members of the Mid-Miami League the past 18 years, Carroll produced league champions in almost every sport. The men's soccer team never dropped a league contest in 18 years, the women's track team won 12 consecutive titles, the football team qualified for the Division II playoffs 6 of the last 7 years, the cross country teams routinely qualified for district and state while the volleyball, women's soccer, and other sports received area recognition for the excellence of our Patriot athletes.

Carroll student-athletes set high standards both in and out of the classroom and this results in a unique situation where excellence in the classroom is balanced by excellence on the court or field.